For engineers who already know the math—but still lose projects. For the last few years, I’ve been sharing technical guides here on Mechanical Design Handbook —how to size a motor, how to calculate fits, and (as you recently read) how to choose between timing belts and ball screws. But after 25 years in industrial automation, I realized something uncomfortable: Projects rarely fail because the math was wrong. They fail because: The client changed the scope three times in one week. A critical vendor lied about a shipping date (and no one verified it). The installation technician couldn’t fit a wrench into the gap we designed. University taught us the physics. It didn’t teach us the reality. That gap is why I wrote my new book, The Sheet Mechanic . This is not a textbook. It is a field manual for the messy, political, and chaotic space between the CAD model and the factory floor. It captures the systems I’ve used to survive industrial projec...
The Failure Scenario: You are printing at 150mm/s. Suddenly, a loud "CLICK-CLICK" noise comes from the X-axis. Your print instantly shifts 5mm to the right. The rest of the print is ruined.
Figure 1: A "Layer Shift" on a calibration cube. The motor lost synchronization during a fast travel move, causing the printer to lose its X/Y coordinate home.
The Cause: This is a Lost Step (Desynchronization). Your motor hit its "Corner Speed" limit. The magnetic field was spinning faster than the rotor could follow, causing the magnets to slip.
While you might think you need a "bigger motor," the real problem is usually Back EMF. This guide explains why torque vanishes at high speed and how to fix it.
Table of Contents
Advertisement
1. Engineering Deep Dive: Why Torque Drops
Most beginners look at "Holding Torque" and assume the motor is that strong all the time. This is false.
The Torque Curve Rule: As a stepper motor spins faster, its torque drops rapidly. A NEMA 17 that holds 50 N.cm at standstill might only have 10 N.cm at 1200 RPM.
Figure 2: The Torque Curve. Notice how torque stays flat (Constant Torque) until "Corner Speed," then plummets (Constant Power). This drop-off is where layer shifts happen. Note: Values are for illustration only.
Why? It's called Back EMF (Electromotive Force).
As the motor spins, it acts like a generator, creating a voltage that pushes back against your driver. At high speeds, this "Back Voltage" fights the driver so hard that current cannot get into the coils fast enough.
Engineering Formula: Current (I) is limited by the motor's speed (ω) and Back EMF constant (Ke):
Current (I) ≈ (Vsupply - Ke·Ï‰) / Impedance
This means as speed (ω) rises, Current drops, and Torque vanishes.
Figure 3: Think of Voltage as pressure. At high speed, the motor generates its own pressure (Back EMF) pushing back. If your Supply Voltage (Green) isn't higher than the Back EMF (Red), no current flows.
2. The "Corner Speed" Limit
Corner speed is the critical RPM where the motor transitions from its Constant Torque region to the Constant Power region. Above this speed, torque plummets.
If your nozzle hits a tiny blob of plastic during a fast travel move above corner speed, the motor desynchronizes. It doesn't just "slow down"—it skips a specific number of electrical steps (usually 4 full steps), causing the layer shift seen in Figure 1.
3. Solution A: Higher Voltage (48V)
Looking at the formula above, the only way to fight Back EMF is to increase Vsupply. This is why professional CNC machines don't use 12V or 24V.
- 12V System: Hits corner speed very early (~300 RPM).
- 24V System: Standard for modern 3D printers. Doubles the corner speed.
- 48V System: Professional grade. Pushes current into the coils 4x faster than 12V, allowing for extreme acceleration without skipping steps.
4. Solution B: Inertia Matching (NEMA 23)
If voltage isn't enough, you may need a larger rotor. A NEMA 23 motor has a larger diameter rotor, which provides more leverage (Torque).
Figure 4: The NEMA 23 (Right) offers 3x the holding torque of the NEMA 17 (Left), but requires a 3.0A external driver.
Advertisement
5. Common Questions (FAQ)
Q: Why does my motor click but not move?
A: This is called 'Stalling.' It means the load is heavier than the motor's available torque. Check for mechanical binding, or lower your acceleration settings.
Q: Will upgrading to NEMA 23 make my printer faster?
A: Not necessarily. NEMA 23 motors have higher rotor inertia. If you put a heavy NEMA 23 on a light 3D printer gantry, the added weight might actually force you to lower your acceleration.
🔧 Build a Better Motion System
Don't let one weak component ruin your machine's precision. Complete your design with our full motion control series:
- Guidance: Linear Rails vs Rods (Fixing Ringing Artifacts)
- Transmission: Timing Belts vs Ball Screws (Fixing Backlash)
- Drive Selection: NEMA 17 vs NEMA 23 Sizing Guide
- Coupling: Flexible vs Rigid Couplers (Fixing Z-Banding)
You fixed the layer shift. Can you fix the deadline slip?
The Sheet Mechanic is your guide to Project Management for Engineers.
About the Author:
This article is written by a mechanical design engineer specializing in industrial automation, sensor selection, and closed-loop control systems.
This article is written by a mechanical design engineer specializing in industrial automation, sensor selection, and closed-loop control systems.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Comments