For engineers who already know the math—but still lose projects. For the last few years, I’ve been sharing technical guides here on Mechanical Design Handbook —how to size a motor, how to calculate fits, and (as you recently read) how to choose between timing belts and ball screws. But after 25 years in industrial automation, I realized something uncomfortable: Projects rarely fail because the math was wrong. They fail because: The client changed the scope three times in one week. A critical vendor lied about a shipping date (and no one verified it). The installation technician couldn’t fit a wrench into the gap we designed. University taught us the physics. It didn’t teach us the reality. That gap is why I wrote my new book, The Sheet Mechanic . This is not a textbook. It is a field manual for the messy, political, and chaotic space between the CAD model and the factory floor. It captures the systems I’ve used to survive industrial projec...
The Failure Scenario: A 100 HP induction motor on a loaded conveyor is started Direct-On-Line (across the line). The massive starting torque snaps the drive belts, while the 600% current spike causes a voltage dip that resets PLCs across the factory floor. To fix this, you install a $4,000 Variable Frequency Drive (VFD), but you program it to run at a fixed 60Hz.
The Cause: You solved the mechanical shock and the inrush current, but you drastically over-specified the solution. You paid for continuous frequency control when all you needed was a controlled ramp-up.
Mechanically, an AC induction motor is a brute-force device. Managing how it accelerates a heavy inertial mass requires understanding the electrical differences between voltage control and frequency control. This guide explains the physics of Soft Starters versus VFDs.
Table of Contents
Advertisement
1. The Physics of Starting: LRA vs FLA
When an AC induction motor is stationary, its internal resistance is extremely low. If you connect it directly to line power (Direct-On-Line / DOL), it draws Locked Rotor Amps (LRA). This is typically 600% to 800% of the motor's Full Load Amps (FLA).
Simultaneously, the motor outputs roughly 150% to 250% of its rated torque in a fraction of a second (depending on the NEMA design class). This violent acceleration destroys gearboxes, stretches roller chains, and causes severe mechanical fatigue on motor shafts.
Figure 1: Direct-On-Line starting creates a massive current spike. Soft Starters limit this mechanically, while VFDs keep current directly proportional to the load.
2. Soft Starters: SCRs and the Torque Penalty
A Soft Starter controls inrush current by manipulating Voltage. It uses solid-state devices called Silicon Controlled Rectifiers (SCRs) to "chop" the AC sine wave, only letting a portion of the voltage through to the motor. As the motor accelerates, the SCRs open wider until the motor receives full line voltage.
Once at full speed, an internal bypass contactor closes, taking the SCRs out of the circuit. This means a soft starter generates very little heat during normal operation.
The Torque Penalty (The Voltage Squared Rule):
In an induction motor, starting torque is proportional to the square of the applied voltage. If a soft starter drops the starting voltage to 50% to limit inrush current, the starting torque drops to 25% of its normal capacity.
In an induction motor, starting torque is proportional to the square of the applied voltage. If a soft starter drops the starting voltage to 50% to limit inrush current, the starting torque drops to 25% of its normal capacity.
Because of this massive torque penalty, Soft Starters are excellent for high-inertia but low-friction loads (like centrifugal fans and water pumps). However, if you apply a soft starter to a heavily loaded inclined conveyor, the motor may simply stall, humming until the thermal overload trips.
3. VFDs: PWM, V/Hz Ratio, and Full Torque
A Variable Frequency Drive (VFD) takes a completely different approach. It alters both Voltage and Frequency simultaneously.
The VFD rectifies incoming AC power into a DC bus, then uses Insulated-Gate Bipolar Transistors (IGBTs) to fire rapid pulses of DC power—a process called Pulse Width Modulation (PWM)—to simulate a new AC sine wave at any frequency you desire.
The V/Hz Advantage
By keeping the Volts-per-Hertz ratio constant (e.g., 460V / 60Hz = 7.6 V/Hz), the magnetic flux inside the motor remains saturated. This allows a properly tuned VFD to deliver rated torque from zero speed without drawing excessive inrush current. The motor can slowly and smoothly tear a fully loaded conveyor belt from a dead stop.
However, VFDs come with significant engineering drawbacks:
- Continuous Heat: The IGBTs are always switching, generating continuous thermal losses that require active cooling.
- Harmonics & dv/dt: High-speed PWM switching creates severe voltage spikes (high dv/dt) and common-mode noise. This often requires expensive line reactors or shielded VFD cables to prevent interference with nearby PLCs.
- Bearing Fluting: Common-mode voltages can induce capacitive discharge through the motor bearings. This electrical arcing physically pits the steel bearing races (EDM pitting), destroying them prematurely.
Figure 2: Soft Starters (Left) are compact and use internal bypass contactors. VFDs (Right) require substantial heat sinks and cooling fans for continuous IGBT operation.
Advertisement
4. Engineering Selection Matrix
| Parameter | Soft Starter | VFD (Variable Frequency Drive) |
|---|---|---|
| Starting Torque | Low (Drops via Voltage Squared) | High (Up to 150% at 0 RPM) |
| Speed Control | None (Starts and stops only) | Full continuous control (0 to 100+ Hz) |
| Heat Generation | Low (Only during ramp; bypassed at speed) | High (Continuous switching losses) |
| Harmonic Noise | Minimal (Only distorts during ramp) | High (Requires shielding or filters) |
| Best Application | Fans, Centrifugal Pumps, Compressors | Loaded Conveyors, Hoists, Mixers, CNC Spindles |
The Specification Rule: If you never plan to change the speed of the motor after it starts, and the starting torque requirement is low, specify a Soft Starter. It saves capital budget, panel space, and heat dissipation requirements. If you need holding torque at zero speed, variable process control, or have a high-friction starting load, specify a VFD.
⚙️ Master Heavy Power Transmission
Designing industrial drive systems requires strict management of torque, inertia, and electrical limits. Explore our full engineering series:
- Shaft Loading: Overhung Load (OHL) Motor Shaft Calculations
- Gearbox Selection: Worm Gear vs Planetary Gearbox Efficiency
- Torque Limits: Ball Detent Torque Limiters & Overload Clutches
- Tension Dynamics: Conveyor Belt Tension Calculation (T1/T2)
You optimized the inrush current. Can you optimize the procurement cycle?
The Sheet Mechanic is the field manual for the chaotic space between the CAD model and the factory floor. Learn how to manage vendors, defend your designs, and prevent downstream project failures.
About the Author:
This article is written by a mechanical design engineer with over 25 years of experience in industrial automation, material handling, and power transmission specification.
This article is written by a mechanical design engineer with over 25 years of experience in industrial automation, material handling, and power transmission specification.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Comments